Logo What's After the Movie
A Good Old Fashioned Orgy

A Good Old Fashioned Orgy 2011

Test your knowledge of A Good Old Fashioned Orgy with our quiz!

A Good Old Fashioned Orgy Plot Summary

Read the complete plot summary and ending explained for A Good Old Fashioned Orgy (2011). From turning points to emotional moments, uncover what really happened and why it matters.


Eric Keppler, portrayed by Jason Sudeikis, is a thirty-something man who embodies the spirit of an eternal party lover. Living in his father’s spacious house in the Hamptons, he frequently hosts extravagant themed parties with his eclectic group of friends. One of the most notable events is the “White Trash Bash” that takes place on July 3, where familiar faces gather, including his ex-girlfriend Sue Plummer, played by Michelle Borth, the nerdy workaholic Adam Richman, embodied by Nick Kroll, the laid-back Mike McCrubber, portrayed by Tyler Labine, the reserved teacher Laura LaCarubba, featured by Lindsay Sloane, the fun-loving Kate played by Lucy Punch, along with her fiancé Glenn, portrayed by Will Forte, and couples therapist Alison Lobel, portrayed by Lake Bell. The guest list also includes law student Doug Duquez, played by Martin Starr, his artistic girlfriend Willow, portrayed by Angela Sarafyan, and Alison’s boyfriend Marcus, played by Rhys Coiro. During the festivities, Eric crosses paths with Kelly, played by Leslie Bibb, who seems to be pregnant.

The very next day, Eric’s father, Jerry, portrayed by Don Johnson, arrives with news that he intends to sell the house. When the friend group returns the following weekend, they discover it is indeed on the market, being handled by real estate agents Dody, played by Lin Shaye, and Kelly. In a bid for one last hurrah, Eric and Mike decide to organize the ultimate party for Labor Day weekend. Reflecting on the younger generation’s more relaxed attitudes toward sex, Eric proposes holding a small orgy among their friends. Initially met with hesitation, the group gradually warms to the idea as Mike and Eric argue that this could be their final opportunity to bond before life pulls them apart. Sue comes forward, admitting her lingering feelings for Eric from high school, yet Eric finds himself drawn to Kelly in a misguided effort to impede the house’s sale. As the dynamics evolve, Doug and Willow join the plan, encouraging Doug to bolster his confidence.

At Kate and Glenn’s wedding that follows, a drunken Adam inadvertently reveals his job loss, triggering his agreement to partake in the orgy out of frustration. The ensuing chaos leads to Glenn discovering their plans, causing rifts within the group. A couple of weeks before the weekend, Eric and Mike visit an underground sex venue disguised as a furniture store named ‘Fred’s Beds’ for insights on orgy participation, collecting tips from Mike’s uncle Vic, humorously played by David Koechner.

As Labor Day approaches, Eric finds himself conflicted over his feelings for Kelly and doubts about the orgy. In a turn of events, Dody agrees to delay the house sale, allowing time for one final party with friends. However, just before the big day, some guests drop out, igniting an argument that threatens to derail their plans. In this turmoil, Sue’s feelings for Eric inadvertently surface, and much to their surprise, Glenn and Kate crash the party intending to join the orgy but end up distracted in their own romantic escapade.

When the day finally arrives, the group struggles with their inhibitions for a bit before ultimately reconciling and diving into what they have planned. Through spirited interactions and unabashed fun, the night unfolds with numerous passionate escapades around the house, drowning their insecurities in alcohol and revelry. The jovial atmosphere leads everyone to let loose, with Eric indulging in a connection with Sue, Mike pairing with Alison, Doug finding solace with Laura, and Adam also getting involved.

As the sun rises after the night’s debauchery, the aftermath leaves everyone nursing hangovers while Mike provides humorous mementos from their adventurous night. Doug’s newfound confidence shines through as he gifts Mike his finished album, with waves of fresh beginnings prompting each character to explore new relationships. By the end, Sue accepts her feelings for Eric, Alison and Marcus reconcile, and new romances blossom between Adam and Laura, leaving Eric to reunite with Kelly on the beach, where they learn that the house sale has hit a snag. Enthusiastic about new possibilities, Eric starts planning yet another gathering for Memorial Day.

A Good Old Fashioned Orgy Timeline

Follow the complete movie timeline of A Good Old Fashioned Orgy (2011) with every major event in chronological order. Great for understanding complex plots and story progression.


Eric's Party Lifestyle

Eric Keppler is characterized as an eternal party lover, living in a lavish house in the Hamptons. He often organizes extravagant themed parties with an eclectic mix of friends, embodying the spirit of celebration.

Hamptons

The White Trash Bash

One of Eric's most memorable parties, the 'White Trash Bash', takes place on July 3. Friends gather to have fun, including notable attendees like his ex-girlfriend Sue and other quirky characters from his life.

July 3 Hamptons

Meeting Kelly

During the festivities of the White Trash Bash, Eric encounters Kelly, who appears to be pregnant. This unexpected meeting stirs Eric's emotions, complicating his perspective as he navigates the relationships with his friends.

Hamptons

Jerry's Big Announcement

The day after the party, Eric's father, Jerry, drops surprising news that he intends to sell the family home. This information shocks Eric, changing the dynamic of his beloved gatherings and prompting reflections on friendship.

Hamptons

The House is on the Market

Returning the following weekend, Eric and his friends discover the house is officially on the market. This new development is managed by real estate agents, including Kelly, adding a layer of complexity to their social dynamics.

Hamptons

Planning the Ultimate Party

In a bid for one last hurrah, Eric and Mike decide to organize a spectacular party for Labor Day weekend. They propose a controversial idea: a small orgy among friends, which ignites a mix of excitement and hesitation.

Labor Day Hamptons

Sue's Confession

As conversations unfold about the upcoming party, Sue reveals her lingering feelings for Eric from high school. This revelation adds emotional tension, especially as Eric's attention is being drawn towards Kelly.

Hamptons

Adam's Revelation

At Kate and Glenn's wedding, Adam drunkenly admits his job loss, leading him to agree to participate in the planned orgy. This incident triggers chaos and heightened emotions within the friend group, igniting conflict.

Wedding Venue

Visiting 'Fred's Beds'

In preparation for the orgy, Eric and Mike visit an underground venue disguised as a furniture store, 'Fred's Beds'. They seek insights on orgy participation, consulting Mike's uncle Vic for comedic advice.

Fred's Beds

Doubt and Conflict

As Labor Day approaches, Eric becomes increasingly conflicted about the orgy concept. Tensions rise within the group when unexpected guest drop-outs occur, sparking arguments that threaten their plans.

Hamptons

Surprising Party Crashers

On the day of the party, Glenn and Kate crash the gathering with intentions of participating in the orgy. However, instead of joining, they become distracted by their own romantic escapades, adding to the chaos.

Hamptons

The Night Unfolds

As the party kicks off, guests struggle with their inhibitions but eventually give in to the festivities. The atmosphere transforms into one of revelry, with connections made, laughter shared, and insecurities put aside.

Labor Day Night Hamptons

Aftermath of the Revelry

The morning after, guests wake up nursing hangovers from the wild night filled with passionate escapades. Mike collects humorous mementos from their adventures as the group reflects on the experiences they shared.

Hamptons

Renewed Relationships

In the heart of the aftermath, Doug showcases newfound confidence as he gifts Mike his finished album. The night leads to reconciliations and budding romances between various members of the group.

Hamptons

Plans for the Future

As Eric reunites with Kelly on the beach, they discover the house sale has encountered problems. This news opens avenues for new possibilities, and Eric excitedly brainstorms another gathering for Memorial Day.

Beach

A Good Old Fashioned Orgy Characters

Explore all characters from A Good Old Fashioned Orgy (2011). Get detailed profiles with their roles, arcs, and key relationships explained.


Eric Keppler (Jason Sudeikis)

Eric is a fun-loving, carefree individual in his thirties, embodying the spirit of the eternal party-goer. He navigates the complexities of friendship, love, and life's changes as he grapples with his feelings for Kelly and the impending sale of his family home.

🎉 Party Lover 💖 Romantic

Sue Plummer (Michelle Borth)

Sue is Eric's ex-girlfriend, who grapples with her unresolved feelings for him. Her presence at the party evokes nostalgia, pushing Eric to reflect on their past relationship and the choices he is currently making.

💔 Ex-Girlfriend 🤔 Reflective

Kelly (Leslie Bibb)

Kelly is introduced as a striking woman who captures Eric's attention. As the impending house sale looms, she unwittingly becomes a catalyst for Eric's emotional conflict, pushing him to confront his feelings and his fear of change.

🌟 Intriguing 💕 Possible Love Interest

A Good Old Fashioned Orgy Settings

Learn where and when A Good Old Fashioned Orgy (2011) takes place. Explore the film’s settings, era, and how they shape the narrative.


Time period

The movie captures contemporary themes reflecting modern social dynamics and relationships. The characters navigate their friendships and romantic entanglements, showcasing a relaxed approach to life's challenges typical in today’s society.

Location

Hamptons

The Hamptons is a popular summer destination known for its picturesque beaches and upscale vacation homes. It is a gathering place for New Yorkers seeking relaxation and social gatherings, often characterized by extravagant parties and events.

🏖️ Beach 🏡 Residence

A Good Old Fashioned Orgy Themes

Discover the main themes in A Good Old Fashioned Orgy (2011). Analyze the deeper meanings, emotional layers, and social commentary behind the film.


💔

Relationships

The film explores the complexities of relationships, both romantic and platonic, as characters reconnect with past loves and examine their current commitments. The dynamics of the friend group shift as feelings emerge, particularly between Eric and Sue, leading to revelations about unaddressed emotions.

🎉

Partying

At the heart of the movie is the celebration of life through parties, encapsulating the joy and chaos that accompanies gatherings of friends. The film highlights how these events act as a backdrop for self-discovery, bonding, and the exploration of newfound connections.

😅

Self-Discovery

As the characters partake in their wild escapades, they confront their inhibitions and insecurities. The journey of self-discovery resonates throughout the film as individuals explore their desires and redefine their relationships in the process.

Movies with Similar Twists and Themes

Uncover films that echo the narrative beats, emotional arcs, or dramatic twists of the one you're exploring. These recommendations are handpicked based on story depth, thematic resonance, and spoiler-worthy moments — perfect for fans who crave more of the same intrigue.


© 2025 What's After the Movie. All rights reserved.