Skip to content
What's After the Movie?
Documentary

What Haunts Us (2018): Cast & Ratings

What Haunts Us (2018) movie poster

What Haunts Us is a 2018 documentary directed by Paige Tolmach, starring Eddie Fischer. It runs 1 hour 12 minutes. Critics gave it 100% on Rotten Tomatoes, and IMDb users rate it 7.0/10.

IMDb rating
7.0/10
Rotten Tomatoes
100%
Echo Score
75
Loading streaming availability…
What Haunts Us (2018) movie poster
Released
Runtime
1h 12m (72 min)
Director
Paige Tolmach
Genre
Documentary
Original language
English
After the credits
No No extra scene
The story

What Is What Haunts Us About?

The premise of What Haunts Us without spoilers.

Set in Charleston, South Carolina, this story explores a dark secret within the Porter Gaud School. A shocking number of graduates from the 1979 class have died by suicide, leaving a lingering sense of unease. Paige Goldberg Tolmach investigates her alma mater's history, confronting a tragic past and the unresolved pain affecting her community. Through her search for answers, she hopes to find redemption and lay the ghosts of the past to rest.

What Haunts Us Themes & Keywords

· 11 tags
  • sexual abuse
  • porter gaud school
  • south carolina
  • pedophile
  • teacher
  • suicide
  • abuse
  • private school
  • charleston south carolina
  • interview
  • 1970s
Loading streaming availability…
Cast & crew

What Haunts Us Cast

Eddie Fischer stars in What Haunts Us. Directed by Paige Tolmach.

Ratings

What Haunts Us Reviews & Ratings

Critics gave What Haunts Us 100% on Rotten Tomatoes, and IMDb users rate it 7.0/10. Our Echo Score gives it 75/100, strongest in character & emotion (90) and weakest in rewatch factor (35).

75 /100

What Haunts Us Echo Score Breakdown

In its exploration of institutional abuse, What Haunts Us combines a measured narrative approach with personal testimonies to deliver a poignant account of complicity and survival. The documentary weaves archival footage, interviews, and animation in a structured sequence that highlights both individual experiences and broader systemic failures. Pacing remains deliberate, allowing key revelations to resonate without sensationalism. While at times revisiting familiar ground, the film sustains engagement through its clear thematic focus. Overall, it offers a compelling examination of abuse and collective responsibility.

Our own 0–100 rating, built from five aspects: art, character, story, the sensory experience and how well a film rewatches.

  • Art & Craft 75

    In terms of direction and craft, What Haunts Us exhibits a clear commitment to documentary basics tempered by modest stylistic flourishes. The film’s use of archival footage and animated reconstructions highlights investigative intentions. Editing maintains focus despite the weight of the material, though some sequences show a first-time director’s tentative pacing. The net result is a competent visual presentation that supports the subject matter without overwhelming it.

  • Character & Emotion 90

    When it comes to character and emotional impact, the film centers personal testimonies to powerful effect. First-hand accounts and on-screen reflections evoke a sense of pain and resilience, establishing depth among survivors and observers. While there is no fictional cast, the documentary’s narrative voices carry authentic emotional weight. Ultimately, the testimonies generate strong personal engagement throughout.

  • Story & Flow 80

    In terms of story and narrative flow, What Haunts Us unfolds its investigation in a coherent sequence that balances background context with emerging revelations. Measured pacing allows interviews and archival materials to build logically toward the film’s thematic conclusions. The structure avoids unnecessary detours, maintaining engagement even as it revisits familiar terrain. Overall, the narrative delivers a focused and impactful exploration of abuse and accountability.

  • Sensory Experience 70

    When evaluating the sensory experience, the film relies primarily on archival audio, courtroom recordings, and minimalist musical cues. Animated segments introduce a visual counterpoint, adding clarity to complex events. Sound design remains understated, ensuring that voicemails and testimony carry the emotional burden. The documentary’s restrained style fosters a sober atmosphere aligned with its serious subject.

  • Rewatch Factor 35

    Regarding rewatch potential, What Haunts Us offers lasting importance but limited repeat viewing appeal due to its distressing subject matter. While insights into systemic abuse may warrant revisiting for educational purposes, the emotional intensity and explicit accounts could deter casual reengagement. In net terms, the documentary’s value is strongest on a single viewing focused on awareness rather than repeated enjoyment.

Seen What Haunts Us?

FAQ

What Haunts Us FAQ: Cast, Runtime & Release Date

Runtime, release date, director, cast, ratings and post-credit scenes of What Haunts Us, each answered in a sentence.

How long is What Haunts Us?

What Haunts Us runs 1 hour 12 minutes (72 minutes).

When was What Haunts Us released?

What Haunts Us was released on May 11, 2018.

Who directed What Haunts Us?

What Haunts Us was directed by Paige Tolmach.

Who is in the cast of What Haunts Us?

What Haunts Us stars Eddie Fischer.

How is What Haunts Us rated?

What Haunts Us has 7.0/10 on IMDb, 100% on Rotten Tomatoes, 74% on TMDB and 3.3/5 on Letterboxd.

Does What Haunts Us have a post-credit scene?

No. What Haunts Us has no extra scene during or after the credits.

Coming soon to your phone

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

From blockbusters to hidden gems: plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when it launches. Your email stays private, always. Learn more about the app