Unthinkable 2010

An American former Delta Force operator, Steven Younger, Michael Sheen makes a videotape that sets the entire drama in motion. In Los Angeles, FBI Special Agent Helen Brody Carrie-Anne Moss and her team are summoned to a high school that has been repurposed by the military as a black site holding Younger, who is using the alias Yusuf Mohamed. The team watches Yusuf’s tape, which shows three nuclear bombs planted in separate U.S. cities, all set to explode at once if his demands aren’t met.

A renowned interrogator, “H” Samuel L. Jackson, is brought in to extract the bombs’ locations. He wastes no time displaying his power, severing one of Yusuf’s fingers to demonstrate the stakes. Brody, appalled by the brutal tactics, tries to intervene, while Saunders Martin Donovan, the senior official overseeing the operation, argues that the threat of ten million deaths justifies torture. The confrontation between ends and means escalates, with Brody trying to play the role of the “good cop” as H pushes further.

Yusuf’s demands arrive: the President must announce a halt to American support for puppet governments and dictatorships in Muslim countries and withdraw troops from there. The group quickly dismisses any chance of satisfying such terms, citing the government’s long-standing stance of not negotiating with terrorists.

Brody pushes back when she suspects Yusuf is exploiting the tension to reveal a moral critique of the United States. Yusuf breaks down and admits the threat was a ruse to provoke a reaction, providing an address to prove it. The team follows the clue to a room that matches the scene in the video, but finds no nuclear device. A soldier unexpectedly pulls Yusuf’s photo down, triggering a nearby C-4 explosion at a shopping mall that leaves 53 people dead.

Filled with anger over the senseless loss of life, Brody returns to Yusuf and cuts his chest with a scalpel. Yusuf remains unfazed and rationalizes the carnage: he had been willing to die to expose U.S. oppression, insisting that the Americans kill that many people every day. The line is chillingly clear: > “Americans kill that many people every day.”

Yusuf’s wife and children are detained, and H threatens to mutilate her right there. Brody and the others move to remove her, but H slashes her throat, and she bleeds out before Yusuf’s eyes. Yusuf does not flinch, so H orders the children brought in. Outside Yusuf’s hearing, he tells everyone that he will not harm the children, yet the order to torture them hangs in the air. Yusuf finally relents and provides three addresses—New York, Los Angeles, and Dallas—but the pressure to coerce him persists.

The group weighs the possibility of an unseen fourth bomb, pointing to the amount of missing nuclear material and the meticulous planning that would allow for an unanticipated device. H argues that the torture was a message about what would happen to Yusuf’s children if he did not cooperate. The government official in charge, who had previously chastised H, attempts to coerce him into continuing the interrogation.

In a final, devastating turn, Yusuf seizes the pistol from the official, requests that Brody look after his children, and then kills himself. Brody walks out of the building with Yusuf’s children, leaving the room in a cautious silence that underscores the moral tension at the heart of the ordeal.