To All a Good Night 2023

During Christmas vacation at the rural Calvin Finishing School for Girls, a prank gone wrong ends in tragedy when a student is killed after being accidentally pushed over a balcony. Two years pass, and on the Friday before Christmas, five students— Nancy, Melody, Leia, Trisha, and Sam—decide to stay behind for a weekend hangout with their respective boyfriends, hoping to turn the holiday into a private gathering rather than a quiet retreat.

That evening, a chilling turn of events unfolds when their classmate Cynthia and her boyfriend are murdered outside the school by a masked assailant wearing a Santa costume. The danger shifts from rumor to visible threat, and the group concocts a plan to keep everyone safe, even if it means bending the rules. In a bid to steady nerves, the girls secretly drug their housemother, Mrs. Jensen, with sleeping milk so she won’t wake during the night.

As night falls, the remaining girls head to a nearby airstrip to meet their boyfriends— T. J., Alex, Tom, and Blake—who have flown in on a private plane. Back at the house, the tension stays high as conversations drift between laughter and fear. Trisha slips away to fetch more beer, only to come face to face with a silhouette in a Santa suit. The killer slits her throat, and when Tom goes to search for her, he is chased outside and struck down with a rock, the killer methodically burying each body in the school’s garden.

In a secluded corner of the house, Sam and Blake share a moment in the parlor, but their intimacy is interrupted by the killer, now adorned in a suit of armor, who shoots Blake with a crossbow and decapitates Sam with an axe. The body count grows more personal and brutal as outside, Ralph the groundskeeper becomes another ominous victim, foreshadowing a deeper threat at play. Inside, Melody uses the moment to lure Alex into a private room, where a disquieting scene unfolds as she gives him a handjob, adding a disturbing layer to the night’s chaotic mood.

The next morning brings a grim discovery: Ralph’s corpse in the woods. Detective Polansky arrives to investigate, urging the remaining students to stay indoors for their own safety and to avoid tipping off potential culprits. He leaves the possibility open that those missing might be victims—or possibly perpetrators—of the earlier deaths. The nightmare continues when Jim, a police officer stationed outside the school, is murdered by the killer with an axe. Leia returns from a shower to find another shocking sight: Sam’s severed head hanging from the shower head, a grotesque reminder of the danger creeping through the halls. Dan, another officer, rushes to intervene but is stabbed in a deadly strike as he enters.

In the wake of the carnage, Nancy and Alex confront the shock of the night’s revelations, while Leia’s psyche begins to unravel, her inability to speak giving way to a disturbing, almost ritualistic dancing and humming. Melody and T. J., meanwhile, stand outside with a lingering sense of unease; they kiss beneath a tree, unaware that danger lurks above them. The killer, hidden in the branches, strangles T. J. with a wire garrote, leaving Melody to stumble back inside in a panic.

The truth emerges in a chilling confrontation: the killer in the Santa costume is Mrs. Jensen, the housemother seeking vengeance for her daughter’s death in the prank two years earlier. She stalks Nancy through the house, forcing a tense chase that ends with Mrs. Jensen pushing Nancy toward the balcony railing. A desperate struggle sends Mrs. Jensen plummeting to her death, but the danger isn’t over. A second Santa-clad assailant appears to be Polansky, the detective’s husband, who reveals himself as part of the sinister plot. He attempts to finish Nancy off with a strangling hold, but Alex intervenes and kills Polansky with a crossbow, ending the human threat as he lies defeated.

With the danger temporarily behind them, Alex and Nancy escape the school, leaving Leia behind to continue her eerie, solitary vigil on the balcony, dancing and singing to herself as the night draws to a close. The house, once full of life and promises, has become a mausoleum of fear, where trust is shattered and every shadow hides a memory of violence. The final image lingers on the scarred halls of the Calvin Finishing School for Girls, a stark reminder that revenge can masquerade as justice and that some secrets are meant to stay buried.