Superman vs. The Elite 2012

Atomic Skull, voiced by Dee Bradley Baker, launches a devastating assault on Metropolis, leaving lives cut short and city streets scarred as emergency sirens wail in the background. As civilians scramble to safety, Superman, George Newbern, arrives to halt the chaos. The encounter becomes not just a test of strength but a test of restraint, and Superman emphasizes the danger of lawless violence while underlining a larger truth: power has to serve the greater good and protect the vulnerable. The moment is charged with moral clarity, even as the aftermath raises questions about the toll of superhero action on everyday people.

In the wake of the chaos, tensions simmer between nations that have long claimed a tenuous peace. The leaders of Bialya and Pokolistan blame one another for a violated treaty, each side stepping into the role of scapegoat as they declare war. The shifting geopolitical landscape casts a pall over Metropolis, reminding viewers that conflicts can echo far beyond a single city, pulling in unlikely players and setting the stage for a showdown that goes beyond mere punch-for-punch heroics.

Superman travels to the front lines in Bialya, where a shocking deployable weapon is brought to bear: a Pokolistani bio-weapon that devastates the Bialyan military in moments. The scale of the threat forces Superman to consider new tactics and alliances, even as the clock ticks down on civilians who could be caught in the crossfire. The desperate need to stop the threat brings a group of vigilantes into the mix—the Elite. The Elite, consisting of Manchester Black, Robin Atkin Downes; Coldcast, Catero Colbert; Menagerie, Melissa Disney; and Hat, Andrew Kishino—arrive with powers that complement and complicate Superman’s own methods. Their arrival reshapes the battlefield and raises uncomfortable questions about how far the powerful should go to safeguard peace.

Back in Metropolis, Superman returns to the city to brief civilians and rescue those trapped on a subway train that has plunged underwater after a terrorist attack. The rescue operation showcases the practical side of heroism: quick thinking, teamwork, and a willingness to risk danger to save strangers. Yet as The Elite demonstrate their brand of decisive action, Superman starts to wonder whether lethal jurisdiction is ever truly justified. Manchester Black, as the team’s strategist and public face, broadcasts a harsh message to the world: the Elite intend to deal with villains using deadly force. The revelation sets up a moral collision course that will test whether the ends truly justify the means.

Driven by a sense of duty and curiosity, Superman follows the trail to Bialya, where Coldcast’s power surges in a brutal confrontation that ends with a devastating neutrino pulse. The force of the blast knocks Superman off his feet, and he is saved only by the timely intervention of the Elite. Teleported to their base—a sentient, macro-organic entity known as Bunny—the Man of Steel finds himself in a facility that defies conventional warfare logic. The base hints at a strange, almost living ecosystem, a stark contrast to the concrete realities of crime fighting that Superman is used to. The clash of ideologies intensifies as Superman argues that killing should never be the default answer, while the Elite’s approach suggests a belief that peace justifies extreme measures.

The tension peaks when Atomic Skull, once imprisoned, breaks free and finds himself confronting the Elite. The fight that follows is brutal and decisive: the Elite secure a hard-won victory, but Manchester makes the painful choice to execute Atomic Skull in the interest of peace. The act is presented as a necessary precaution by the Elite, a moment that forces Superman to reckon with the price of “preventive” violence. In a heavy-handed broadcast, the Elite claim credit for eliminating both Pokolistani and Bialyan leaders, arguing that removing violent influences is the only way to secure lasting stability. The revelation shakes Superman and prompts him to question whether the cost of this approach is too high.

Superman makes clear that he is willing to confront danger, but he insists on keeping civilians out of harm’s way. To separate the two sides from the public, Black teleports them to the Moon and broadcasts the ultimate showdown to the entire planet. On the lunar stage, the two sides exchange blows—Superman standing up to the Elite’s combined power with a resilience born of his commitment to non-lethal justice. He endures a torrent of attacks from Coldcast, Menagerie, and Hat, while Manchester’s telekinetic assaults threaten to overwhelm him. The battle takes a dark turn when Superman uses his powerful, precise abilities to neutralize Manchester’s powers, effectively leveling the playing field and forcing the others to confront the human cost of their tactics.

As the cosmic spectacle unfolds, the fight reaches a turning point: Superman’s counteroffensive culminates in a dramatic moment where Manchester’s power is neutralized, and the Elite’s assault loses its edge. The conflict shifts from a display of raw power to a deeper, quieter question about legitimacy and trust. When the dust settles, Manchester discovers a jarring truth: the world has seen the consequences of their lethal approach, and it is not the justice they claimed to uphold. Superman then reveals a crucial fact—no one was truly defeated; the Elite were transported to the Fortress of Solitude and stripped of their powers, leaving them powerless and physically isolated from the world they sought to police.

In the final reckoning, the people of Earth come to a hard-won realization: violence and killing are not compatible with true justice. The public comes to accept Superman’s philosophy—that lasting peace requires restraint, accountability, and a commitment to protecting civilians above all else. The Elite’s power, once a symbol of decisive action, is shown to be insufficient without a shared ethical center. The story closes on a note of cautious optimism: a restored balance where strength is tempered by responsibility, and a city and a world are prepared to move forward with a renewed sense of moral purpose.