Skip to content
What's After the Movie?
Biographical film

Sister Aimee (2019): Cast & Ratings

Sister Aimee (2019) movie poster

Sister Aimee is a 2019 biographical film directed by Marie Schlingmann, starring Amy Hargreaves as Sister Semple, Gary Teague and Anna Margaret Hollyman. It runs 1 hour 27 minutes. Critics gave it 68% on Rotten Tomatoes and 52 on Metacritic, and IMDb users rate it 5.0/10.

IMDb rating
5.0/10
Rotten Tomatoes
68%
Echo Score
62
Metascore
52
Loading streaming availability…
Sister Aimee (2019) movie poster
Released
Runtime
1h 27m (87 min)
Genre
Biography
Original language
English
After the credits
No No extra scene
The story

What Is Sister Aimee About?

The premise of Sister Aimee without spoilers.

In 1926, Sister Aimee Semple McPherson, a hugely popular and influential evangelist, mysteriously vanishes, leaving her followers devastated. The circumstances surrounding her disappearance lead to speculation and a frantic search. It is revealed that she secretly traveled to Mexico, sparking a media frenzy and raising questions about her motives and the truth behind her actions. The incident profoundly impacts her reputation and the religious landscape of the time.

Sister Aimee Themes & Keywords

· 25 tags
  • evangelist
  • female preacher
  • year 1926
  • religion
  • tent revival
  • los angeles california
  • faith healer
  • miracle
  • writing a book
  • running away
  • road trip to mexico
  • tour guide
+13 more
  • speaking spanish
  • man urinating outside
  • gun
  • knife
  • headline story
  • reference to the mexican revolution
  • reference to pancho villa
  • man's throat slit
  • man shot
  • man bound and gagged
  • police interview
  • police station
  • robe
Loading streaming availability…
Cast & crew

Sister Aimee Cast & Characters

Amy Hargreaves leads the cast as Sister Semple, with Gary Teague as Sister Aimee Believer and Anna Margaret Hollyman as Sister Aimee. Directed by Marie Schlingmann; 13 actors are credited in all.

Also Starring in Sister Aimee

· 9 more
Ratings

Sister Aimee Reviews & Ratings

Critics gave Sister Aimee 68% on Rotten Tomatoes and 52 on Metacritic, and IMDb users rate it 5.0/10. Our Echo Score gives it 62/100, strongest in character & emotion (80) and weakest in rewatch factor (45).

62 /100

Sister Aimee Echo Score Breakdown

Overall, Sister Aimee offers a distinctive portrayal of its central figures but struggles to maintain narrative coherence. While strong performances and imaginative framing generate intermittent interest, erratic tone shifts and pacing lapses dilute engagement. The production’s period details and occasional comedic stylings provide visual charm, yet uneven direction and inconsistent thematic focus hinder lasting appeal. Limited emotional continuity and variable momentum constrain the film’s overall impact. Thus, the movie delivers isolated strengths amid a broadly mixed viewing experience.

Our own 0–100 rating, built from five aspects: art, character, story, the sensory experience and how well a film rewatches.

  • Art & Craft 50

    In terms of direction and production design, Sister Aimee presents an inconsistent craft quality. Some sequences exhibit resourceful period set choices and a light comedic touch, while others feel erratically staged and tonally unsettled. The film’s radio-inspired stylings introduce visual novelty but occasionally lack cohesion. Overall, the cinematic execution alternates between inventive moments and disjointed presentation.

  • Character & Emotion 80

    In terms of acting and emotional resonance, Sister Aimee benefits from a committed ensemble performance. Leading portrayals infuse depth into supporting characters and sustain viewer investment even when the plot falters. The cast’s chemistry and nuanced engagement convey the protagonist’s ambition and inner conflicts authentically. Consequently, character development stands out as one of the film’s most compelling attributes.

  • Story & Flow 65

    In terms of plot coherence and pacing, Sister Aimee oscillates between inventive concepts and uneven execution. Early narrative segments creatively explore self-invention, yet abrupt tone shifts and sporadic pacing issues disrupt engagement. While moments of originality and thematic insight emerge, tangled storytelling and periodic confusion diminish overall flow. Thus, the film’s narrative remains intriguing at times but ultimately yields a fragmented progression.

  • Sensory Experience 60

    In terms of sensory experience, Sister Aimee offers modest audio-visual engagement without standout elements. The period settings and occasional comedic score contribute mild charm, yet the overall sound design and visual cohesion remain serviceable rather than immersive. Limited dynamic range in music and sparse stylistic consistency temper the sensory impact. Overall, sensory attributes are adequate but rarely elevate the viewing experience.

  • Rewatch Factor 45

    In terms of rewatch value, Sister Aimee delivers limited incentive for repeat viewings. While certain performances and inventive moments invite secondary consideration, persistent tonal shifts and narrative inconsistencies reduce lasting appeal. The film’s uneven momentum and serviceable sensory elements fail to establish a compelling return experience. As a result, subsequent viewings are unlikely to significantly enhance overall appreciation.

Videos

Sister Aimee Trailers & Videos

The trailer of Sister Aimee.

Sister Aimee
Details

Sister Aimee Also Known As

15 alternative titles, including “The Pleasure of Your Presence” and “La germana del nóvio”.

Also known as
  • The Pleasure of Your Presence
  • La germana del nóvio
  • Сестра нареченого
  • A Irmã do Noivo
  • 小姑子
  • La hermana del novio
  • Сестра жениха
  • Die Hochzeit meines Bruders
  • Ma belle-sœur bien aimée
  • Sister of the Groom - Il matrimonio di mio fratello
  • Görümce
  • 마이 스위트 크레이지 시스터
+3 more
  • Siostra pana młodego
  • La germana del nuvi
  • 惡姐不讓婚

Seen Sister Aimee?

FAQ

Sister Aimee FAQ: Cast, Runtime & Release Date

Runtime, release date, director, cast, ratings and post-credit scenes of Sister Aimee, each answered in a sentence.

How long is Sister Aimee?

Sister Aimee runs 1 hour 27 minutes (87 minutes).

When was Sister Aimee released?

Sister Aimee was released on September 27, 2019.

Who directed Sister Aimee?

Sister Aimee was directed by Marie Schlingmann.

Who is in the cast of Sister Aimee?

Sister Aimee stars Amy Hargreaves as Sister Semple, Gary Teague as Sister Aimee Believer and Anna Margaret Hollyman as Sister Aimee, among 13 credited actors.

How is Sister Aimee rated?

Sister Aimee has 5.0/10 on IMDb, 68% on Rotten Tomatoes, 52 on Metacritic and 59% on TMDB.

Does Sister Aimee have a post-credit scene?

No. Sister Aimee has no extra scene during or after the credits.

Coming soon to your phone

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

From blockbusters to hidden gems: plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when it launches. Your email stays private, always. Learn more about the app