
Fifteen years after the initial encounter, Corey returns to his class reunion, still affected by his childhood experiences with the Tooth Fairy. However, the fairy has returned, and Corey discovers that the consequences of neglecting dental hygiene can be far more serious than he ever imagined. This time, proper dental care is essential to avoid unforeseen and magical repercussions.
Does Return of the Tooth Fairy have end credit scenes?
No!
Return of the Tooth Fairy does not have end credit scenes. You can leave when the credits roll.
Explore the complete cast of Return of the Tooth Fairy, including both lead and supporting actors. Learn who plays each character, discover their past roles and achievements, and find out what makes this ensemble cast stand out in the world of film and television.

Jake Watkins
Corey

Heather Jackson
Marg

Simon Manley
Ray

Jenna Harris
Tammy

Louisa Warren

Amy Blackthorne
Danielle

AJ Blackwell
Paul

Katie McKenna
Jess

Chelsea Greenwood
Jo

Gus Fithen
Gus

Venetia Cook
Hazel

Anabel Saise
Toothfairy

Mat Sibal
Toothfairy

David Pountain
Toothfairy

Niru Sukanthan
Toothfairy
Discover where to watch Return of the Tooth Fairy online, including streaming platforms, rental options, and official sources. Compare reviews, ratings, and in-depth movie information across sites like IMDb, TMDb, Rotten Tomatoes or Letterboxd.
See how Return of the Tooth Fairy is rated across major platforms like IMDb, Metacritic, and TMDb. Compare audience scores and critic reviews to understand where Return of the Tooth Fairy stands among top-rated movies in its genre.
Return of the Tooth Fairy is overwhelmingly regarded as a poorly executed horror sequel. Reviewers consistently condemn the amateurish production values, weak performances, and incoherent plot, labeling it a painful viewing experience. A few isolated comments note modest improvements over the original and occasional effective scares, but these are far outweighed by the numerous criticisms. Consequently, the film lacks appeal and offers minimal incentive for repeat viewings.
The Movie Echo Score Breakdown for Return of the Tooth Fairy
Art & Craft
In terms of art and craft, the film is described as a low‑budget, home‑video effort with consistently bad camera work, lighting, and special effects. Reviewers compare the visuals to a junior‑high project and highlight poorly executed makeup and set design. No positive remarks about direction or editing are offered, resulting in a markedly low appraisal of the technical execution.
Character & Emotion
When evaluating character and emotion, critics note unconvincing acting, flat performances, and lack of chemistry among the cast. The main protagonist receives a brief mention as “cute,” but overall the portrayals are deemed pitiful and amateur. Even the few reviewers who acknowledge minor character motivations still criticize the general acting quality, leading to a weak score for this aspect.
Story & Flow
The story and flow receive mixed feedback. Many reviewers find the plot incoherent, citing an implausible school‑reunion premise and sluggish pacing. However, some acknowledge a modestly interesting premise involving a traumatized individual and a supernatural threat, describing it as an improvement over the original. The balance of negative and limited positive observations places this aspect in the lower‑mid range.
Sensory Experience
Sensory experience is heavily criticized for poor sound design, pervasive background noise, and inconsistent audio levels. Visual style suffers from washed‑out lighting and cheap effects, with reviewers likening it to a child’s costume. While a few note occasional eerie moments, the dominant view is that the auditory and visual components detract significantly from the viewing experience.
Rewatch Factor
Rewatch factor is uniformly low, with most reviewers advising against future viewings and describing the film as a waste of time. Only a single comment hints at modest enjoyment, but the prevailing sentiment is that the movie lacks lasting appeal or entertainment value, resulting in a minimal score for repeatability.
It appears Return of the Tooth Fairy does not have a summary available yet. Please consider requesting one.

Coming soon on iOS and Android
From blockbusters to hidden gems — dive into movie stories anytime, anywhere. Save your favorites, discover plots faster, and never miss a twist again.
Sign up to be the first to know when we launch. Your email stays private — always.
Immerse yourself in the magic of cinema with live orchestral performances of your favorite film scores. From sweeping Hollywood blockbusters and animated classics to epic fantasy soundtracks, our curated listings connect you to upcoming film music events worldwide.
Explore concert film screenings paired with full orchestra concerts, read detailed event information, and secure your tickets for unforgettable evenings celebrating legendary composers like John Williams, Hans Zimmer, and more.
Discover the central themes, ideas, and keywords that define the movie’s story, tone, and message. Analyze the film’s deeper meanings, genre influences, and recurring concepts.
Explore the various alternative titles, translations, and other names used for Return of the Tooth Fairy across different regions and languages. Understand how the film is marketed and recognized worldwide.
Browse a curated list of movies similar in genre, tone, characters, or story structure. Discover new titles like the one you're watching, perfect for fans of related plots, vibes, or cinematic styles.
What's After the Movie?
Not sure whether to stay after the credits? Find out!
Explore Our Movie Platform
New Movie Releases (2025)
Famous Movie Actors
Top Film Production Studios
Movie Plot Summaries & Endings
Major Movie Awards & Winners
Best Concert Films & Music Documentaries
Movie Collections and Curated Lists
© 2025 What's After the Movie. All rights reserved.