Skip to content
What's After the Movie?
Crime thriller

Lies We Tell (2024): Cast, Ratings & Box Office

Lies We Tell (2024) movie poster

Lies We Tell is a 2024 crime thriller directed by Lisa Mulcahy, starring Agnes O'Casey as Maud, David Wilmot and Chris Walley. It is based on Uncle Silas by Sheridan Le Fanu and Claire Connolly. It runs 1 hour 29 minutes and earned $82,914 worldwide. It won 3 awards from 5 nominations, including Best Actress in a Lead Role at the IFTA Awards 2024. IMDb users rate it 6.5/10.

IMDb rating
6.5/10
worldwide gross
$82.9K
awards won
3
Echo Score
75
Loading streaming availability…
Lies We Tell (2024) movie poster
Released
Runtime
1h 29m (89 min)
Director
Lisa Mulcahy
Genres
Crime , Mystery , Thriller
Original language
English
After the credits
No No extra scene
The story

What Is Lies We Tell About?

The premise of Lies We Tell without spoilers, adapted from Uncle Silas by Sheridan Le Fanu and Claire Connolly.

In 1864 Ireland, orphaned heiress Maud Ruthyn is living under the care of her mysterious uncle, Silas. Defying the advice of trusted advisors, she welcomes Silas’s family into her secluded manor. However, the arrival of Maud’s long-lost relatives uncovers a complex network of hidden agendas and disturbing secrets concealed within the estate.

Lies We Tell Themes & Keywords

· 10 tags
  • dark
  • female protagonist
  • heiress
  • period drama
  • ireland
  • orphaned protagonist
  • reference to sheridan le fanu
  • 1860s
  • rape
  • based on novel
Loading streaming availability…
Cast & crew

Lies We Tell Cast & Characters

Agnes O'Casey leads the cast as Maud, with David Wilmot as Silas and Chris Walley as Edward. Directed by Lisa Mulcahy; 11 actors are credited in all.

Also Starring in Lies We Tell

· 7 more
From the director

More from Lisa Mulcahy

More films directed by Lisa Mulcahy: The Legend of Longwood and Gift of the Magi.

Full filmography
Ratings

Lies We Tell Reviews & Ratings

IMDb users rate Lies We Tell 6.5/10. Our Echo Score gives it 75/100, strongest in art & craft (82) and weakest in story & flow (68).

75 /100

Lies We Tell Echo Score Breakdown

Lies We Tell delivers a richly textured period thriller anchored by strong performances and meticulous production design, creating an immersive Victorian atmosphere. The film builds sustained tension through careful pacing and effective cinematography, though its climax feels rushed and the resolution lacks full coherence. While occasional bluntness in character development and visual variety temper its impact, the overall experience remains compelling and memorable.

Our own 0–100 rating, built from five aspects: art, character, story, the sensory experience and how well a film rewatches.

  • Art & Craft 82

    The direction and cinematography convey a distinctive Victorian aesthetic, with striking compositions and period‑accurate production design that enhance the film’s mood. Visual sequences often employ a restrained palette that heightens tension, and several shots are notably effective. Minor criticisms note occasional blandness and a hurried editing rhythm in the final act, slightly reducing overall visual impact.

  • Character & Emotion 78

    Performances form the core strength, with the lead delivering a nuanced, emotionally resonant portrayal that anchors the narrative. Supporting actors contribute solidly, providing credible chemistry and depth in key scenes. Nevertheless, some secondary characters feel underdeveloped, and their motivations are not fully articulated, leading to uneven emotional engagement.

  • Story & Flow 68

    The plot weaves a gothic mystery with a compelling twist, maintaining audience interest through measured pacing and gradual tension buildup. Originality is evident in its exploration of psychological abuse within a period setting. However, the climax accelerates abruptly, resulting in a rushed conclusion that compromises narrative coherence.

  • Sensory Experience 73

    The film’s soundscape and score complement the visual tone, using restrained music and ambient sounds to amplify suspense. Production design and costumes faithfully render the Victorian era, contributing to an immersive sensory experience. While the overall auditory and visual palette is effective, occasional flatness in lighting and muted sound reduces the intensity in certain scenes.

  • Rewatch Factor 75

    The sustained tension and strong central performance give the film a persuasive rewatch appeal, encouraging viewers to revisit its layered dynamics. The period aesthetic and intricate sound design provide rewarding details on subsequent viewings. Yet, the rushed ending and occasional narrative unevenness may lessen repeat enjoyment for some audience members.

Box office

Lies We Tell Box Office

Lies We Tell grossed $82,914 worldwide.

2024 box office

Worldwide gross

$82.9K

International
$82.9K
Awards

Lies We Tell Awards & Nominations

Lies We Tell won 3 awards from 5 nominations, including Best Actress in a Lead Role at the IFTA Awards 2024.

3 wins5 nominations1 ceremony

  • Irish Film & Television Awards logo
    IFTA Awards 2024 3 wins · 5 nominations
    • Won Best Actress in a Lead Role
    • Won Best Director
    • Won Best Script
    • Nominated Best Actor in a Lead Role
    • Nominated Best Actor in a Supporting Role
Videos

Lies We Tell Trailers & Videos

2 videos: 2 trailers.

Trailer
  • Trailer Lies We Tell | Official Trailer
Details

Lies We Tell Also Known As

7 alternative titles, including “El legado” and “El llegat”.

Also known as
  • El legado
  • El llegat
  • V sevření lží
  • Hazugságaink
  • W matni kłamstw
  • Лъжите, които казваме
  • Minciunile pe care le spunem

Seen Lies We Tell?

FAQ

Lies We Tell FAQ: Cast, Box Office & Awards

Runtime, release date, director, cast, box office, ratings, the book behind it and awards of Lies We Tell, each answered in a sentence.

How long is Lies We Tell?

Lies We Tell runs 1 hour 29 minutes (89 minutes).

When was Lies We Tell released?

Lies We Tell was released on September 13, 2024.

Who directed Lies We Tell?

Lies We Tell was directed by Lisa Mulcahy.

More films by Lisa Mulcahy

Who is in the cast of Lies We Tell?

Lies We Tell stars Agnes O'Casey as Maud, David Wilmot as Silas and Chris Walley as Edward, among 11 credited actors.

How much did Lies We Tell make at the box office?

Lies We Tell grossed $82,914 worldwide.

How is Lies We Tell rated?

Lies We Tell has 6.5/10 on IMDb and 65% on TMDB.

Is Lies We Tell based on a book?

Yes. Lies We Tell is adapted from Uncle Silas by Sheridan Le Fanu and Claire Connolly.

What awards did Lies We Tell win?

Lies We Tell won 3 awards from 5 nominations, including Best Actress in a Lead Role at the IFTA Awards 2024.

Coming soon to your phone

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

From blockbusters to hidden gems: plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when it launches. Your email stays private, always. Learn more about the app