His and Her Christmas 2005

Two Bay Area newspapers clash in a story of ambition, media power, and a growing pull between rivalry and romance. At the center, the sharp-witted Liz Madison Dina Meyer writes the advice column for the Marin County Voice, a warm, community-focused paper that is fighting to survive in a changing world. Across town, Tom Lane [David Sutcliffe] shines as the star columnist for the San Francisco Sun, a larger paper owned by a powerful media conglomerate that is always looking to raise his profile—potentially through a new television venture built around his persona. The tension intensifies when the Voice learns that the Sun’s owners have quietly bought their paper, with the likely aim of folding it into the Sun’s operations and letting go of the staff.

Liz refuses to roll over. She pivots her column from gentle guidance to a bold editorial that centers on the true meaning of Christmas and the Voice’s role in the community. Her fearless, entertaining stance resonates with readers, and the Voice’s circulation surges. The sudden updraft in popularity makes the idea of closing the Voice lose some of its teeth for the Sun’s owners, who begin to reconsider their plan. But this success comes with a price: keeping the Voice afloat could jeopardize Tom’s carefully crafted path to television stardom, and the balance between their careers and ambitions becomes delicate and personal.

In response, Tom counters with a column of his own, arguing for practicality and a different take on the holiday season. The once-cutting, professional clash between Liz and Tom quickly becomes a personal duel as they spar with words, wit, and a growing, undeniable chemistry that neither can easily deny. Their friends and family weigh in, nudging them toward a familiar adage that there’s a fine line between love and hate, and that the heart might be pulled toward something more than petty rivalry.

As the story unfolds, the battle lines of journalism blur with matters of the heart. Liz’s fervor to defend the Voice and its community impact collides with Tom’s hunger for career advancement, creating a complex push-and-pull dynamic. The film explores how two rival voices can still be drawn to each other, and how the crowded world of news, entertainment, and personal longing can intersect in unexpected ways, all set against a backdrop of holiday spirit, newsroom politics, and the everyday longing for connection.