Skip to content
What's After the Movie?
Documentary

Crime + Punishment (2018): Cast, Ratings & Box Office

Crime + Punishment (2018) movie poster

Crime + Punishment is a 2018 documentary directed by Stephen T. Maing, starring Manuel 'Manny' Gomez, Rukia Lumumba and Sandy Gonzales. It runs 1 hour 52 minutes and earned $18,644 worldwide. Critics gave it 93% on Rotten Tomatoes and 88 on Metacritic.

Rotten Tomatoes
93%
worldwide gross
$18.6K
Echo Score
77
Metascore
88
Loading streaming availability…
Crime + Punishment (2018) movie poster
Released
Runtime
1h 52m (112 min)
Director
Stephen T. Maing
Genre
Documentary
Original language
English
Studio
Hulu
After the credits
No No extra scene
The story

What Is Crime + Punishment About?

The premise of Crime + Punishment without spoilers.

This documentary explores the experiences of black and Latino police officers in New York City who bravely blow the whistle on illegal quotas and discriminatory policing practices. Through intimate and unprecedented access, the film follows these officers and a private investigator as they confront decades of injustice and risk their careers to expose the devastating impact on communities. Their personal struggles are deeply connected to their fight for accountability and reform within the police force.

Loading streaming availability…
Cast & crew

Crime + Punishment Cast

Manuel 'Manny' Gomez leads the cast, with Rukia Lumumba and Sandy Gonzales. Directed by Stephen T. Maing.

From the director

More from Stephen T. Maing

More films directed by Stephen T. Maing, best-rated first: Union and High Tech, Low Life.

Full filmography
Ratings

Crime + Punishment Reviews & Ratings

Critics gave Crime + Punishment 93% on Rotten Tomatoes and 88 on Metacritic. Our Echo Score gives it 77/100, strongest in art & craft (80) and weakest in rewatch factor (60).

77 /100

Crime + Punishment Echo Score Breakdown

Overall, Crime + Punishment presents a potent investigative portrait of systemic policing issues. It balances thorough critique and personal storytelling with measured pacing and a cohesive visual style. The documentary foregrounds the experiences of whistleblowers, fostering emotional engagement through candid interviews and sustained narrative focus. While some note a desire for deeper exploration of broader institutional motivations, the film’s clarity and urgency leave a compelling impression. In essence, it stands as an essential critique of law enforcement practices.

Our own 0–100 rating, built from five aspects: art, character, story, the sensory experience and how well a film rewatches.

  • Art & Craft 80

    Direction and cinematography emerge as a relative highlight. The use of sustained drone shots creates an ominous atmosphere without feeling gratuitous. The low-key visual approach supports the intimate tone of the whistleblowers’ narratives. Though production design remains unobtrusive, the editing maintains a deliberate flow that reinforces the film’s measured pacing. Overall, the visual craft underpins the documentary’s investigative focus.

  • Character & Emotion 80

    When it comes to character depth, the film excels at humanizing its subjects. Allowing officers to speak candidly conveys their personal struggle and the emotional toll of confronting systemic pressures. The documentary highlights moments of tension and empathy, from whispered conversations to confrontational exchanges. This focus on lived experience produces genuine emotional resonance. In sum, the character portrayal offers a nuanced look at individuals caught between duty and conscience.

  • Story & Flow 75

    In terms of story and flow, the documentary maintains a coherent narrative through measured pacing. It chronicles the whistleblowers’ struggle with clear structure, balancing background context and unfolding drama. Some reviewers note the film stops short of probing broader motivations, but most praise its compelling engagement with the quota system’s impact. Overall, the plot coherence and original perspective foster sustained interest from beginning to end.

  • Sensory Experience 70

    Focusing on sensory experience, the film employs a restrained audio-visual style that supports its investigative tone. The soundtrack remains unobtrusive, allowing recorded testimonies and ambient sound to carry emotional weight. Visually, the color palette stays muted, reinforcing the documentary’s serious subject matter without distraction. This cohesive approach creates an immersive atmosphere. Overall, the sensory design subtly enhances the film’s emphasis on real-world stakes.

  • Rewatch Factor 60

    Regarding rewatch value, the documentary’s importance lies primarily in its informative content rather than repeat entertainment. The detailed accounts and real-life stakes provide points of reference on subsequent viewings, though the low-key presentation may reduce viewer expectancy for repeated plays. Still, the film’s relevance to ongoing conversations on law enforcement maintains its lasting appeal. Ultimately, its educational focus offers moderate incentive for revisits.

Box office

Crime + Punishment Box Office

Crime + Punishment grossed $18,644 worldwide.

2018 box office

Worldwide gross

$18.6K

US & Canada
$18.6K
Videos

Crime + Punishment Trailers & Videos

The trailer of Crime + Punishment.

Crime + Punishment Trailer (Official) • A Hulu Original Documentary
Details

Crime + Punishment Also Known As

3 alternative titles, including “Crime + Castigo” and “크라임 + 퍼니시먼트”.

Also known as
  • Crime + Castigo
  • 크라임 + 퍼니시먼트
  • 罪与罚

Seen Crime + Punishment?

FAQ

Crime + Punishment FAQ: Cast, Box Office & Runtime

Runtime, release date, director, cast, box office, ratings and post-credit scenes of Crime + Punishment, each answered in a sentence.

How long is Crime + Punishment?

Crime + Punishment runs 1 hour 52 minutes (112 minutes).

When was Crime + Punishment released?

Crime + Punishment was released on August 24, 2018.

Who directed Crime + Punishment?

Crime + Punishment was directed by Stephen T. Maing.

More films by Stephen T. Maing

Who is in the cast of Crime + Punishment?

Crime + Punishment stars Manuel 'Manny' Gomez, Rukia Lumumba and Sandy Gonzales.

How much did Crime + Punishment make at the box office?

Crime + Punishment grossed $18,644 worldwide.

How is Crime + Punishment rated?

Crime + Punishment has 93% on Rotten Tomatoes, 88 on Metacritic, 69% on TMDB and 3.6/5 on Letterboxd.

Does Crime + Punishment have a post-credit scene?

No. Crime + Punishment has no extra scene during or after the credits.

Coming soon to your phone

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

From blockbusters to hidden gems: plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when it launches. Your email stays private, always. Learn more about the app