Black Island 2021

Art & Craft

In terms of art and craft, the film shows flashes of visual competence. Critics highlight the chilling, windswept scenery and several reviewers commend the strong photography and well‑executed shot composition. However, direction is frequently described as poor or overly straightforward, and pacing issues affect the overall editing rhythm. The balance of visual merit against directional flaws leads to a moderate assessment of the film’s artistic execution.

Character & Emotion

Character and emotion receive a mixed response, with performances ranging from competent to amateur. Alice Dwyer is singled out for a solid portrayal, yet many actors are labeled average, bland, or unengaging. Some reviewers find the characters likable, while others describe them as poorly constructed and lacking sympathy. The disparity in acting quality and limited emotional resonance results in a below‑average character rating.

Story & Flow

The story and flow are generally viewed as unoriginal and sluggish. Multiple reviewers criticize the predictable plot, forced death scenes, and slow pacing that only accelerates in the final half‑hour. While a few note a decent premise and occasional intrigue, the consensus points to a weak narrative structure and limited engagement. Consequently, the storytelling earns a modest score.

Sensory Experience

Sensory experience shows relative strength, especially in visual style. The remote, windswept setting and effective cinematography are repeatedly praised. Conversely, the soundtrack is described as generic or overly teen‑oriented, detracting from immersion. Overall, the film’s visual cohesion compensates for its auditory shortcomings, placing the sensory aspect slightly above average.

Rewatch Factor

Rewatch factor is low, with many reviewers labeling the film as watchable only for a single, time‑filling viewing. The lack of narrative payoff, repetitive thrills, and overall boredom diminish desire for repeat viewings. Although a few users recommend it as an occasional thriller, the prevailing sentiment suggests limited lasting appeal and low replay value.