Between Miracles 1971

In a cramped, under-resourced private hospital, a skilled surgeon is urgently called to operate on Benedetto Parisi in his critical condition after a suicide attempt. In the waiting room, his companion, Joan Micheli, is pregnant with him, and she consents to the risky procedure. His mother, Immacolata, looms in the wings like a speculative observer, hoping to shepherd a social and economic windfall by marrying Giovanna off to a lawyer friend of the family.

The film then unfolds with a tapestry of flashbacks that trace Benedict’s early life. He grows up an orphan in a small village in the Latin Valley, under the scrutiny of a maiden aunt whose religiosity masks a life of contradictions. The boy is haunted by nocturnal noises from his aunt’s room and is taught to interpret what he sees through a prism of guilt and piety. On the eve of his first communion, he is given an effigy of “celestial friends”—saints meant to accompany him on his path to Jesus. The night brings a startling turn when his aunt’s lover is momentarily hid in a closet, leading to a childlike blurring of sin and sanctity. The next morning, Benedict works to fix a saintly image on the wall, glimpses his aunt naked, and is told not to confess the incident to the priest for fear of offending the “celestial friends.” The sacramental moment of his first communion becomes an ordeal as he feels the host stuck in his throat, and he bolts, only to fall into a ravine. Although the village fears he has perished, he survives, and the crowd proclaims him a miracle boy. Dressed as a saint, Benedict is carried in a procession, and his aunt seizes the opportunity to rid herself of this troublesome burden by sending him to a Franciscan monastery, where he grows into adulthood.

Within the friary, Benedict is welcomed for his simplicity and naivety. The brothers await a sign that will reveal his true calling. A traveling salesman, Uncle Checco, materializes as a catalyst for change when a glimpse of a nude photo in his car stirs Benedict’s longings for a world beyond the cloister. One day, while laboring in the fields, a snake bites a visiting schoolteacher; Benedict saves her by sucking out the venom, a act that becomes a feverish symbol of awakening desire. He confesses to the friars that he has found “the sign” they awaited and soon joins Uncle Checco in traveling the countryside, selling cloth and undergarments.

As a traveling vendor, Benedict moves through towns where fashion and desire collide. The work brings him into contact with women who are drawn to the new styles he sells, and he navigates opportunities that test his religious scruples. He meets a beautiful village girl who comes night after night to buy panties, and their interaction blossoms into a complex relationship. The story then introduces a pharmacist, Oreste Micheli, who becomes a sympathetic, secular counterpoint to Benedict’s scruples. Benedict falls in love with Joan Micheli’s daughter, and the family dynamics deepen as the pharmacist’s daughter becomes a central presence in his life. The romance with Giovanna deepens, and Benedict contemplates marriage with her, a plan that would satisfy his mother’s ambitions while tempting his own evolving desires. Yet he remains torn between the duty to marry and the pull of a freer, more intimate life with Giovanna.

Meanwhile, the relationship with Giovanna deepens as she helps Benedict shed his strict boundaries, and they begin living as husband and wife for six years, though not formally wed. The mother, Immacolata, observes the unfolding arrangement with a practical eye, pressing for every possible advantage in the family’s standing. Complications mount when Giovanna’s pregnancy becomes a tangible indicator of a life Benedict is only just beginning to chart for himself. Orestes Micheli, the pharmacist, experiences a heart attack, and the family mobilizes around his last rites, a moment that crystallizes the fragile balance Benedict has struck between faith, family duty, and personal desire. The awkward, tense ritual of the dying man’s conferral of a blessing—and his kiss on the crucifix—shocks Benedict, who rushes away in a desperate bid to escape a future he can not yet imagine.

The culmination unfolds in the private hospital where Benedict’s survival hinges on a successful operation. As the medical team works to stabilize him, the drama crescendos to a final, chilling moment: the surgeon’s measured report that the operation succeeded, followed by the resonant confirmation that the outcome was, in effect, “a miracle.”

It was a miracle!