Skip to content
What's After the Movie?
Thriller

Babysitter’s Nightmare (2018): Cast & Ratings

Babysitter’s Nightmare (2018) movie poster

Babysitter’s Nightmare is a 2018 thriller directed by Jake Helgren, starring Brittany Underwood as Daphne Hart, Reagan Pasternak and Jet Jurgensmeyer. It runs 1 hour 30 minutes. Its Echo Score is 39/100.

Loading streaming availability…
Babysitter’s Nightmare (2018) movie poster
Released
Runtime
1h 30m (90 min)
Director
Jake Helgren
Genre
Thriller
Original language
English
After the credits
No No extra scene
The story

What Is Babysitter’s Nightmare About?

The premise of Babysitter’s Nightmare without spoilers.

After being dismissed from her nursing job due to negligence allegations, Daphne takes a babysitting position with Karen Andrews, a woman living in the suburbs. She's responsible for caring for Karen's diabetic son on the weekends. When a local babysitter is found dead, Daphne becomes increasingly suspicious of the strange events occurring around the Andrews' home and fears for her own safety.

Babysitter’s Nightmare Themes & Keywords

· 4 tags
  • babysitter
  • stalker
  • babysitter in peril
  • villainess
Loading streaming availability…
Cast & crew

Babysitter’s Nightmare Cast & Characters

Brittany Underwood leads the cast as Daphne Hart, with Reagan Pasternak as Karen Andrews and Jet Jurgensmeyer as Toby Andrews. Directed by Jake Helgren; 7 actors are credited in all.

Also Starring in Babysitter’s Nightmare

· 3 more
From the director

More from Jake Helgren

More films directed by Jake Helgren: A Carpenter Christmas Romance, The Naughty List of Mr. Scrooge, The Holiday Proposal Plan and A Cowboy Christmas Romance.

Full filmography
Ratings

Babysitter’s Nightmare Reviews & Ratings

Our Echo Score gives it 39/100, strongest in story & flow (45) and weakest in art & craft (30).

39 /100

Babysitter’s Nightmare Echo Score Breakdown

Babysitter’s Nightmare delivers a largely uneven experience, with frequent criticism of its script, acting, and factual accuracy that outweighs occasional moments of amusement. Reviewers note a handful of effective scares and an unexpectedly enjoyable climax, yet the film’s inconsistent tone and underdeveloped characters limit its broader appeal. The net impression is that the movie falls short of genre expectations, offering limited replay value for most viewers.

Our own 0–100 rating, built from five aspects: art, character, story, the sensory experience and how well a film rewatches.

  • Art & Craft 30

    In terms of art and craft, the film shows minimal polish in direction and visual execution. Reviewers describe the production as loose, with a script that struggles to support coherent editing or design choices. While some technical moments pass without glaring errors, the overall lack of craftsmanship results in a modest visual impression.

  • Character & Emotion 35

    Character and emotional depth are largely underdeveloped, with many critics labeling performances as awful or unconvincing. The lead actress receives occasional praise, yet the ensemble is described as inexperienced, and dialogue often feels forced. Limited chemistry and flat character arcs contribute to a weak emotional resonance throughout the film.

  • Story & Flow 45

    The story presents a mixed narrative, offering occasional suspense and a surprise reveal that some viewers appreciated. However, pacing is criticized as either boring or rushed, and plot coherence suffers from implausible medical details and a thin premise. While a few reviewers found the storyline tolerable, overall engagement remains inconsistent.

  • Sensory Experience 40

    Sensory elements receive little specific commentary, implying an average execution of sound and visual style. No notable strengths in soundtrack or sound design are highlighted, and the visual presentation does not compensate for narrative weaknesses. The lack of distinct sensory cues leads to a fairly neutral but unremarkable experience.

  • Rewatch Factor 45

    Rewatch potential is divided; some viewers enjoy the film’s inadvertent humor and occasional scares, suggesting a modest replay value. Others deem it unworthy of a second viewing due to poor script and acting. The mixed reception yields a middling rewatch factor that may appeal only to fans of campy, low‑budget horror.

Videos

Babysitter’s Nightmare Trailers & Videos

The trailer of Babysitter’s Nightmare.

Official Trailer
Details

Babysitter’s Nightmare Also Known As

9 alternative titles, including “Nuit de terreur pour la baby-sitter” and “A Stranger Outside”.

Also known as
  • Nuit de terreur pour la baby-sitter
  • A Stranger Outside
  • Убить няню
  • 保姆之死
  • Kill the Babysitter
  • Mai giocare con la babysitter
  • Invasão Noturna
  • Un extraño acecha
  • Zavřená v pasti

Seen Babysitter’s Nightmare?

FAQ

Babysitter’s Nightmare FAQ: Cast, Runtime & Release Date

Runtime, release date, director, cast and post-credit scenes of Babysitter’s Nightmare, each answered in a sentence.

How long is Babysitter’s Nightmare?

Babysitter’s Nightmare runs 1 hour 30 minutes (90 minutes).

When was Babysitter’s Nightmare released?

Babysitter’s Nightmare was released on August 7, 2018.

Who directed Babysitter’s Nightmare?

Babysitter’s Nightmare was directed by Jake Helgren.

More films by Jake Helgren

Who is in the cast of Babysitter’s Nightmare?

Babysitter’s Nightmare stars Brittany Underwood as Daphne Hart, Reagan Pasternak as Karen Andrews and Jet Jurgensmeyer as Toby Andrews, among 7 credited actors.

Does Babysitter’s Nightmare have a post-credit scene?

No. Babysitter’s Nightmare has no extra scene during or after the credits.

Coming soon to your phone

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

From blockbusters to hidden gems: plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when it launches. Your email stays private, always. Learn more about the app