This Is Our Christmas 2018

Art & Craft

In terms of art and craft, reviewers note the film’s attractive cinematography and period‑inspired visual style. The shots of Big Bear, snowy landscapes, and classic Hollywood touches are praised for their charm, and direction is described as solid despite low‑budget constraints. Some criticism mentions uneven acting, but overall the visual execution is viewed as competent and appealing.

Character & Emotion

When evaluating character and emotion, the cast receives generally positive remarks for their likable presence and moments of genuine feeling. Performances by Margaret O'Brien and the teenage lead are highlighted as resonant, and the chemistry among family characters is described as endearing. However, a few reviewers criticize the acting as appalling and the characters as lacking depth, tempering the overall praise.

Story & Flow

Regarding story and flow, the narrative is seen as simple, grounded, and centered on classic holiday themes, which many find enjoyable and easy to follow. The emotional arc of a teen coping with loss is noted as a strength. Conversely, some users cite an excess of plot lines and a jumbled storyline, leading to a mixed assessment of narrative coherence.

Sensory Experience

The sensory experience receives strong commendation, with reviewers highlighting the festive soundtrack, bright visual palette, and nostalgic 1940s‑style production design. Scenic shots of snow‑covered mountains, bakery interiors, and iconic Los Angeles locations are described as beautiful and immersive, creating a cohesive holiday ambience that enhances viewer enjoyment.

Rewatch Factor

Rewatch factor is rated highly, as families report repeated viewings and children expressing a desire to see the film again. The comforting storyline, charming characters, and seasonal nostalgia contribute to lasting appeal. The film is frequently recommended for relaxed family gatherings during the holidays, reinforcing its suitability for multiple watches.