Skip to content
What's After the Movie?
Thriller

The Wrong Stepmother (2019): Cast & Ratings

The Wrong Stepmother (2019) movie poster

The Wrong Stepmother is a 2019 thriller directed by David DeCoteau, starring Corin Nemec as Michael, Cindy Busby and Vivica A. Fox. It runs 1 hour 26 minutes. Its Echo Score is 38/100.

Loading streaming availability…
The Wrong Stepmother (2019) movie poster
Released
Runtime
1h 26m (86 min)
Director
David DeCoteau
Genre
Thriller
Original language
English
Studio
Hybrid
After the credits
No No extra scene
The story

What Is The Wrong Stepmother About?

The premise of The Wrong Stepmother without spoilers.

After the loss of his wife, Michael has been raising his two daughters as a single parent. His life takes a turn when Maddie enters the picture, but she harbors a hidden desire for him and his family, creating a complicated and unsettling situation.

The Wrong Stepmother Themes & Keywords

· 37 tags
  • stalking
  • new girlfriend
  • snooping
  • father daughter relationship
  • lifetime movie
  • distrust
  • hidden camera
  • psycho
  • murder
  • strangulation
  • teenage daughter
  • doctor patient confidentiality
+25 more
  • teenage boy
  • guidance counselor
  • maniac
  • considering engagement
  • sister sister relationship
  • psychopath
  • sassy teenage girl
  • manipulation
  • older sister protecting younger sister
  • paranoid woman
  • danger
  • pick up from school
  • widowed father
  • high school
  • cell phone call
  • coworker coworker friendship
  • messenger app
  • cell phone
  • internet search
  • 38 year old woman
  • woman with mental health issues
  • female stalker
  • knife
  • reference to violent parent
  • lie
Loading streaming availability…
Cast & crew

The Wrong Stepmother Cast & Characters

Corin Nemec leads the cast as Michael, with Cindy Busby as Maddie and Vivica A. Fox as Ms. Price. Directed by David DeCoteau; 18 actors are credited in all.

Also Starring in The Wrong Stepmother

· 14 more
From the director

More from David DeCoteau

More films directed by David DeCoteau: The Wrong Obsession, Make or Bake Christmas, A Nanny to Die For and Million Dollar Lethal Listing.

Full filmography
Ratings

The Wrong Stepmother Reviews & Ratings

Our Echo Score gives it 38/100, strongest in character & emotion (48) and weakest in sensory experience (32).

38 /100

The Wrong Stepmother Echo Score Breakdown

Overall, the film registers a predominantly negative reception, with most viewers citing fundamental flaws in its writing, performances, and production values. While a few reviewers acknowledge occasional entertainment value and commend certain cast members, the consensus highlights a predictable plot, flat visuals, and limited replay appeal. This imbalance results in a low aggregate rating that reflects the general disappointment expressed across user feedback.

Our own 0–100 rating, built from five aspects: art, character, story, the sensory experience and how well a film rewatches.

  • Art & Craft 35

    In terms of direction and visual execution, reviewers repeatedly note a lack of stylistic coherence and inexpensive production design, describing sets as dated and cinematography as undistinguished. Editing receives no commendation, and the overall craft conveys a low‑budget, formulaic aesthetic that fails to elevate the material.

  • Character & Emotion 48

    When evaluating the performances, the majority of comments describe acting as subpar, criticizing the lead’s portrayal and the overall credibility of the characters. A minority of viewers, however, praise Cindy Busby’s villainous turn and find the child actors comparatively engaging. Nonetheless, the prevailing impression is that character work detracts from the film’s effectiveness.

  • Story & Flow 42

    The narrative is widely regarded as predictable and riddled with logical gaps, with multiple reviewers highlighting clichéd dialogue and implausible plot developments. A few comments note that the story manages brief entertainment value, yet the overall consensus underscores weak pacing and a lack of originality that undermines audience engagement.

  • Sensory Experience 32

    In the sensory domain, reviewers mention an uninspired visual style, describing the set dressing as dated and the overall aesthetic as bland. No comments address the soundtrack or sound design, implying a lack of notable auditory elements. Consequently, the sensory experience contributes little to the film’s appeal.

  • Rewatch Factor 35

    Regarding rewatch potential, the overwhelming sentiment is that the film offers little incentive for a second viewing, with critics citing its predictable plot and weak execution. Only a small fraction of reviewers express intent to watch again, citing occasional enjoyment or favored cast members.

Videos

The Wrong Stepmother Trailers & Videos

The trailer of The Wrong Stepmother.

THE WRONG STEPMOTHER on Lifetime Movie Network on Friday July 5th!
Details

The Wrong Stepmother Also Known As

6 alternative titles, including “Effroyable belle-mère” and “Zła macocha”.

Also known as
  • Effroyable belle-mère
  • Zła macocha
  • Una extraña en la familia
  • A Madrasta Errada
  • Una matrigna pericolosa
  • Mama vitregă greșită

Seen The Wrong Stepmother?

FAQ

The Wrong Stepmother FAQ: Cast, Runtime & Release Date

Runtime, release date, director, cast and post-credit scenes of The Wrong Stepmother, each answered in a sentence.

How long is The Wrong Stepmother?

The Wrong Stepmother runs 1 hour 26 minutes (86 minutes).

When was The Wrong Stepmother released?

The Wrong Stepmother was released on July 5, 2019.

Who directed The Wrong Stepmother?

The Wrong Stepmother was directed by David DeCoteau.

More films by David DeCoteau

Who is in the cast of The Wrong Stepmother?

The Wrong Stepmother stars Corin Nemec as Michael, Cindy Busby as Maddie and Vivica A. Fox as Ms. Price, among 18 credited actors.

Does The Wrong Stepmother have a post-credit scene?

No. The Wrong Stepmother has no extra scene during or after the credits.

Coming soon to your phone

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

From blockbusters to hidden gems: plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when it launches. Your email stays private, always. Learn more about the app