Brooklyn 45 2023

Drama

History

Horror

Runtime

92 min

Language

English

Directed by

Ted Geoghegan

Made by

Shudder

Test your knowledge of Brooklyn 45 with our quiz!

Brooklyn 45 Plot Summary

Read the complete plot summary and ending explained for Brooklyn 45 (2023). From turning points to emotional moments, uncover what really happened and why it matters.

On the night of December 27, 1945, a group of military veterans and lifelong friends gather at the home of their esteemed commander, Clive “Hock” Hockstatter (Larry Fessenden), in Park Slope, New York, to enjoy some cocktails. This reunion includes Marla Sheridan (Anne Ramsay), her husband Bob (Ron E. Rains), as well as Archibald “Archie” Stanton (Jeremy S. Holm) and Paul DiFranco (Ezra Buzzington).

While the friends reminisce, Hock is burdened by the recent suicide of his mentally ill wife, Susan (Lucy Carapetyan), who tragically took her life after no one believed her claims that their German neighbor, Hildegard (Kristina Klebe), was spying for Hitler. In a moment of grief, Hock reveals his fading belief in organized religion, resorting to spiritualism for solace. He persuades his friends to partake in an unexpected séance in a desperate hope to reach out to Susan.

The séance reveals itself to be a shocking success, with candles igniting, a closet door banging, and Susan’s ectoplasmic arm emerging as the music of Louis Jordan blasts from the radio. In a moment of desperation, Hock breaks the circle and reaches out, causing Susan’s spirit to recede. Overwhelmed by the occurrence and grappling with the reality of an afterlife, Hock shockingly pulls out a pistol and takes his own life.

Amidst the chaos, the closet bursts open, revealing Hildegard, bound and gagged. As she breaks free, the friends question her identity and motives, resulting in tension and suspicion amongst the group. Archie reveals he’s committed a war crime, while Marla showcases an unexpected brutality during her interrogation of Hildegard, much to Bob’s astonishment.

Realizing they are trapped in the room by mystical forces, Marla believes the only escape is to finish the séance. As Hock’s spirit possesses his lifeless body, he demands that the group kill Hildegard to secure their freedom. The situation escalates when Susan’s ghost appears, accusing Hildegard of her murder. The revelations send Archie into a panic, forcing him to confront his horrific past.

In a frenzy, Hock’s possessed body becomes increasingly violent, leading to a series of betrayals and tragic events. Bob, now wielding the gun, shoots at Paul in self-defense before turning the weapon on Hildegard, killing her amid the turmoil. Bob, feeling compelled to act for survival’s sake, drops the gun, shaken by the horrors that unfolded.

Upon fulfilling Hock’s malevolent demand, the parlor doors finally swing open. Bob, Marla, and Archie exit, but not without the weight of their shared trauma. Archie, grappling with his own guilt, decides to turn himself in. As Bob and Marla sit in their car, the emotional toll of the night engulfs them, ending with them overwhelmed in silence and tears, processing the grim events they just endured.

Brooklyn 45 Timeline

Follow the complete movie timeline of Brooklyn 45 (2023) with every major event in chronological order. Great for understanding complex plots and story progression.

Veterans' Reunion Begins

On December 27, 1945, a group of military veterans and lifelong friends gather at the home of their commander, Clive 'Hock' Hockstatter, in Park Slope, New York. They come together to enjoy cocktails and reminisce about their past experiences.

1945-12-27 Park Slope, New York

Hock's Personal Grief

As the reunion unfolds, Hock reveals the burden of his wife's recent suicide, which has left him haunted. Susan suffered from mental illness and was not believed when she claimed their neighbor Hildegard was a spy for Hitler.

A Desperate Séance

In an attempt to find solace, Hock persuades his friends to participate in a séance to reach out to his deceased wife. The group, initially hesitant, goes along with Hock's unorthodox method of dealing with his loss.

The Séance Reveals the Supernatural

During the séance, unexpected phenomena occur, including candles igniting and a closet door banging. In a shocking moment, Susan's ectoplasmic arm emerges, startling the group and forcing them to confront the reality of the supernatural.

Hock's Tragic Decision

Overwhelmed by the events of the séance, Hock succumbs to despair and draws a pistol, tragically taking his own life. This shocking act further deepens the group’s sense of shock and hopelessness in the face of their experiences.

Hildegard's Revelation

In the chaos following Hock's death, the closet bursts open, revealing Hildegard, bound and gagged. Her presence sparks immediate tension and suspicion among the friends, leading them to question her role in the night’s events.

Archie's Confession

Amidst the growing tension, Archie reveals he has committed a war crime, adding layers of complexity to their situation. The atmosphere grows increasingly fraught as the group realizes the extent of each other's hidden pasts.

Marla's Uncharacteristic Brutality

During the interrogation of Hildegard, Marla showcases unexpected brutality, shocking both Bob and the group. Her aggression reveals deeper psychological issues stemming from their traumatic histories.

The Demand for Murder

Realizing they are trapped by mystical forces, Marla proposes finishing the séance to escape. Unbeknownst to them, Hock's spirit possesses his lifeless body, making a chilling demand that they kill Hildegard for their freedom.

Susan's Ghostly Accusation

As tensions reach a fever pitch, Susan’s ghost appears and accuses Hildegard of her murder. This confrontation sends Archie into a panic, forcing him to face the trauma of his own past actions during the war.

Betrayals and Violence Erupt

The atmosphere turns increasingly violent as Hock's possessed body drives the group to betray each other. In an act of self-defense, Bob shoots Paul and then turns the gun on Hildegard amidst the rising chaos.

Bob's Desperate Actions

After killing Hildegard, Bob drops the gun, shaken and horrified by the violence that unfolded. The emotionally charged situation highlights the primal instincts for survival triggered by their traumatic experiences.

Escape from the Haunted Room

With Hock’s demands fulfilled, the parlor doors finally swing open, allowing Bob, Marla, and Archie to escape. However, they are left carrying the weight of the night’s horrific events and their choices.

Archie's Decision to Surrender

As they leave, Archie, burdened by guilt and the ghosts of his past, decides to turn himself in for his war crimes. His choice symbolizes a desperate attempt at seeking redemption amid the chaos of the night.

The Aftermath

In their car, Bob and Marla sit in silence, engulfed by the emotional weight of the horrific events they have just experienced. Overwhelmed with tears, they process the trauma and pain, hinting at the enduring scars left by the night.

Brooklyn 45 Characters

Explore all characters from Brooklyn 45 (2023). Get detailed profiles with their roles, arcs, and key relationships explained.

Clive Hockstatter (Larry Fessenden)

Clive, also known as Hock, is the esteemed commander struggling with grief over his wife's recent suicide. His conflict with faith and search for closure lead him to hold the séance, revealing deep vulnerabilities. Hock's character evolves from a figure of authority to a tragic symbol of despair as the night unfolds.

🔍 Grief 💔 Despair 📑 Leadership

Marla Sheridan (Anne Ramsay)

Marla is a complex character who showcases unexpected brutality during the interrogation of Hildegard. Her actions reveal a fierce loyalty but also a willingness to cross moral boundaries under duress. Marla's journey is marked by conflicting emotions as she navigates friends’ betrayals and the chaos of the night.

💪 Strength ⚔️ Brutality

Bob Sheridan (Ron E. Rains)

Bob serves as a moral compass amidst the turmoil, yet is pushed to violence in self-defense. His emotional evolution is evident as he grapples with survival instincts and the haunting aftermath of their actions. Bob's final resolution reflects the heavy burden of trauma shared among the group.

🧠 Morality ⚖️ Self-Defense

Archibald Stanton (Jeremy S. Holm)

Archie is a troubled veteran who grapples with guilt over war crimes. His character's struggles manifest as panic and irrational behavior during the séance, revealing the deep psychological scars left by combat. Archie's arc culminates in a critical decision to confront his past, adding a layer of complexity to the narrative.

😨 Panic 📖 Redemption

Paul DiFranco (Ezra Buzzington)

Paul is a pragmatic character whose responses to the supernatural events are grounded yet conflicted. He finds himself in the center of the chaos, ultimately facing the consequences of defend actions. His role provides a balance between skepticism and the emotional weight of their situation.

🔍 Skepticism ⚔️ Conflict

Hildegard Baumann (Kristina Klebe)

Hildegard is presented as a mysterious character bound by circumstances during the séance. Initially perceived as a potential threat, her character becomes a focal point of suspicion and tension within the group. Her true motives and identity challenge the veterans’ perceptions, culminating in a dramatic revelation.

❓ Mystery 🔗 Intrigue

Susan Hockstatter (Lucy Carapetyan)

Susan’s tragic backstory casts a long shadow over the narrative, as her struggles with mental illness and eventual death influence Hock's actions. Although deceased, her presence is felt through the séance, serving as a catalyst for the unfolding drama. Susan’s character embodies the emotional pain and unanswered questions of the night.

💔 Loss 📜 Mental Illness

Brooklyn 45 Settings

Learn where and when Brooklyn 45 (2023) takes place. Explore the film’s settings, era, and how they shape the narrative.

Time period

December 27, 1945

The movie is set shortly after the end of World War II, a period marked by significant social and emotional upheaval. Veterans returned home, grappling with memories of war and loss while trying to reintegrate into civilian life. This specific time reflects both the relief of peace and the haunting effects of trauma, which are central to the characters’ experiences.

Location

Park Slope, New York

Park Slope, a historic neighborhood in Brooklyn, New York, is known for its well-preserved brownstones and a vibrant community. The area is filled with tree-lined streets, cozy cafes, and local boutiques, making it a welcoming space for families and friends to gather. The home of Clive Hockstatter serves as a pivotal setting for the reunion of the veterans, symbolizing camaraderie amidst personal turmoil.

🏙️ Location 🏠 Home

Brooklyn 45 Themes

Discover the main themes in Brooklyn 45 (2023). Analyze the deeper meanings, emotional layers, and social commentary behind the film.

🕯️

Spirituality

The theme of spirituality permeates the film as characters grapple with loss and the existence of an afterlife. Hock's shift from organized religion to spiritualism highlights the desperate search for solace amidst grief. The séance serves as a conduit for exploring unresolved feelings and the connections to those they've lost.

🕵️‍♂️

Guilt

Guilt serves as a powerful theme, particularly for Archie, who confronts his actions during the war. As secrets surface during the night, the weight of past decisions influences the characters' actions and reactions. This internal battle is exacerbated by the supernatural events, forcing each character to confront their moral dilemmas.

🔪

Betrayal

Betrayal emerges as characters turn against one another under extreme pressure. The horrifying events during the séance reveal the fragility of trust among friends. As fear and paranoia take hold, the dynamics shift dramatically, leading to violent outcomes that alter their relationships forever.

Brooklyn 45 Ending Explained

Unravel the ending of Brooklyn 45 (2023) with our detailed explanation. Understand the final scenes, character fates, and unresolved questions.

In the climax of Brooklyn 45, the spirits of Susan and Clive become relentless in preventing the characters from leaving the haunted room, especially if Hildegard remains alive. Despite various attempts, Paul is the first to raise his gun to shoot Hildegard, driven by fear and xenophobia, but Bob intervenes, shooting and killing Paul instead. Knowing that the ghosts are still exerting their power and that the only way to escape is to free themselves from the spirits’ grip, Bob also kills Hildegard. His actions seem to be motivated by a desperate desire to escape the torment and the haunted cycle of their sins. After this violent act, Marla, Bob, and Archie manage to leave the house, but the damage is profound—Marla is devastated by Bob’s brutality, and Archie contemplates turning himself in for war crimes. The ending underscores how the characters, haunted by their past sins committed during the war—such as Clive’s war crime of bombing a kindergarten, Archie’s killing of children, and Hildegard’s possible involvement in espionage—are unable to escape their guilt. The spirits serve as manifestations of their collective guilt and unresolved trauma, and in their attempt to purge the ghosts, they ultimately destroy their moral selves, illustrating that these ghosts of the past are impossible to escape from without confronting and accepting the darkness within themselves. The film ends on a tragic note, highlighting that the horror of past actions continues to haunt them, tearing their lives and relationships apart in the process.

Movies with Similar Twists and Themes

Uncover films that echo the narrative beats, emotional arcs, or dramatic twists of the one you're exploring. These recommendations are handpicked based on story depth, thematic resonance, and spoiler-worthy moments — perfect for fans who crave more of the same intrigue.