May December 2023

In 2015, actress Elizabeth Berry arrives in Savannah, Georgia, for research on her upcoming role in an independent film. She takes on the character of Gracie Atherton-Yoo (Julianne Moore), who, back in 1992, made headlines at the age of 36 for her controversial affair with Joe Yoo (Charles Melton), a 13-year-old schoolmate of her son Georgie (Cory Michael Smith). This affair began when they both worked at a pet store, leading to a difficult prison sentence for Gracie, during which she gave birth to Joe’s child.

Now, 23 years later, Gracie and Joe are married with three children: Honor (Piper Curda), who is away at college, and twins Charlie (Gabriel Chung) and Mary (Elizabeth Yu), who are on the verge of graduating from high school. Honor was born while Gracie was incarcerated. Gracie expresses a strong desire for Elizabeth to be more involved in the filmmaking process, steering away from the stereotypical Hollywood actress who merely occupies space on screen.

Hosting a barbecue at her home, Gracie extends an invitation to Elizabeth, during which she interviews Gracie and Joe about their unconventional relationship. The couple still faces significant backlash from the community, which manifests in hostile gestures, such as leaving boxes of feces at their doorstep. Gracie’s friend, Rhonda (Andrea Frankle), often witnesses how Gracie treats Joe more like a child than a partner, exercising control over his actions and decisions.

As Elizabeth immerses herself in Gracie’s world, she learns about Gracie’s upbringing and the challenges she faced growing up with her brothers. Their initial meeting occurred at the pet store, where Joe, seeking a job as a seventh grader, caught Gracie’s eye. Georgie, now a family man with children of his own, recounts how the scandal shattered his childhood and alienated him from his peers. During her research, Elizabeth confronts the emotional complexities surrounding Gracie’s past, discovering that Gracie feels little to no remorse for her decisions.

A poignant visit to the pet store—the scene of their initial tryst—leads Elizabeth to reenact the moment alone, seeking to understand the depth of the situation. Gracie had been with the store since October 1990, managing it effectively despite other stores opening nearby. Elizabeth interviews Gracie’s ex-husband, Tom (D.W. Moffett), and Georgie, who share conflicting perspectives on Gracie’s character, illustrating the intricate web of their family dynamics.

While navigating her own complex interactions, Elizabeth engages in discussions about the emotional layers of acting during intimate scenes at the twins’ high school event, emphasizing how difficult it can be to draw the line between genuine and performative feelings. Gracie’s ongoing efforts to relate with Elizabeth deepen their relationship, as they bond over make-up lessons and baking pineapple cake.

As time unfolds, Joe reveals his passion for raising butterflies, sharing moments of vulnerability with his son Charlie as they explore substances together. The family’s graduation celebration reveals tensions with Georgie’s family, as Honor expresses her dissatisfaction with a film being made about Gracie’s life—an event that stirs old familial wounds. Gracie and Elizabeth both navigate the fallout of their past actions and the intricacies of their relationships, with tensions boiling over when Georgie seeks a job from Elizabeth in exchange for details about Gracie’s past.

When intimate boundaries blur between Elizabeth and Joe, complications arise, igniting conversations that question the nature of power and consent. As graduation day arrives, profound transformations occur, particularly for Joe, who grapples with his past and newfound emotions.

In a heart-wrenching finale, Elizabeth revisits significant moments from Gracie’s life in front of the camera, lending a new perspective to the narrative of this intricate family saga while capturing the undeniable reality of what it meant to be ensnared by societal judgments and personal choices. With an insistence on authenticity, Elizabeth leads the charge to redefine how Gracie’s story is told, culminating in an emotional exploration that resonates throughout the filming process as she continuously seeks to make the portrayal ever more real.